Thursday, January 19, 2012

Stewart and Colbert: Defying American Commonplaces


As I sat at my desk Tuesday night, chuckling to myself at the absurdity of Jon Stewart and Steven Colbert’s collaborative episode, I thought to myself, “The Daily Show and Colbert Report are purely genius!” Although many associate Stewart with making foolish statements and just “poking fun” at those in power, he is doing more than just simply expediting his jokes on Comedy Central, he is satirizing the American political system and democracy itself.

On the episode, the audience understands that Colbert is running for President, however, Colbert also wanted to sponsor a Political Action Committee—the financial arms of interest groups—and under federal law a candidate can not correspond with PACs. So who better to sponsor such a committee? Jon Stewart! And what did he name it? “The Definitely NOT Coordinating with Stephen Colbert Super PAC!” This facetious and ironic slogan challenges the audience’s mind and gets them to think of how PACs really do coordinate with the candidates even though it is illegal to do so.

On the episode, the two go back and forth on the phone with a high profile lawyer stating that they are not “coordinating” with another, however, the viewer sees the ridiculousness in this as the two comedians clearly signal to each other what they like and dislike (be it the different aspects of campaigning including commercials to location of where the money is to be spent). Stewart and Colbert’s use of sarcasm, irony, and satire demonstrate how the wealthy and the elite control the American political system and power is gained through the “almighty dollar”. Here, both men use logos—rhetorical appeals to logic and reasoning—and ethos—appeals to character and credibility—to stimulate the audience and to allow the witnesses to register the absurdity of campaign financing and America’s elitist-run government. Additionally, the episode sends the message that money can purchase power, speech, and a winning election. This is a perfect example of how Stewart and Colbert dramatize conflict for entertainment purposes in order to articulate their message clearly and to bring political matters to the attention of the American public.  

Aside from the Super PAC example, in the episode, Stewart also applauds Republican nominee Newt Gingrich’s inability to realize that he insulted African Americans in the country through a quote he used. Now, this is a perfect example of how Stewart uses logos. Although he does not explicitly say his message (in this instance that Gingrich did in fact make a racist comment), the viewer still understands the message from the video clip Stewart shows and the sarcastic jokes, diction, and actions he completes.

Today, various people associate rhetoric with an inability to accomplish, but you see it is not like that at all. In fact, rhetoric is a positive in society! It allows people to make decisions, resolve disputes, and mediate public discussions of important issues. Comedians Stewart and Colbert just happen to be masters of rhetoric and use their powers to defy America’s commonplaces—one being that rhetoric is negative.  


2 comments:

  1. I am so glad someone used this! I saw this episode yesterday in my poli sci 001. I am fairly sure everyone in that class now judges me for the way I laugh. I cannot wait to see where this goes. If you remember, Stephen ran for president in 2008 but dropped out after not very long. How far do you think he will take it this time?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Life would be so much less funny without Colbert and Stewart. I had heard talks of this earlier and to see the video, I about died. Kudos!

    ReplyDelete